Replication studies in political science journals

Blog

Replication studies play a critical role in advancing knowledge and ensuring the robustness of findings. Some journals are increasingly recognising this by introducing dedicated article categories for replication studies. These categories provide a clear pathway for researchers to share their work replicating and scrutinising existing studies, fostering transparency, and improving the reliability of published research.

At least seven political science journals now publish a specific article type for replication studies. All accept replication submissions focused on articles previously published in their own journal or in other relevant outlets. Other journals may accept replication studies under different categories, such as Research Notes, but the list below highlights those with a dedicated replication category.

Journal h5-index Format Name Length Limit
American Political Science Review 82 Replication NA
Public Administration 47 Replication Study NA
Political Communication 46 Replication 30 pages
Political Science Research and Methods 44 Replication NA
Research & Politics 29 Replication Study 2k words
Canadian Journal of Political Science 25 Replication 2k words
Journal of Experimental Political Science 25 Replication Study 3k words

This list is sourced from my political science journals app, which you may also find useful for exploring additional article types and journal options.